Skip to main content

Oklahoma State University

Bob Fenimore

One Of The Most Important Chapters In Oklahoma State Football History

December 28, 2015 | Cowboy Football

NEW ORLEANS – On New Year's Day, 1946, Oklahoma State (then Oklahoma A&M) scored a 33-13 win over St. Mary's of California in the Sugar Bowl to cap the only undefeated season in school history. On New Year's Day, 2016 – 70 years later to the day – Oklahoma State again hunts for Sugar Bowl glory.
 
But first, a look back at the 1946 game, which matched the fifth-ranked Aggies against the seventh-ranked Gaels in front of a then-record crowd of 75,000 at Tulane Stadium.
 

 
Coached by Jim Lookabaugh, Oklahoma A&M was the bigger and more experienced squad, but St. Mary's countered with a flashy offense rooted in deception that helped to mitigate the Aggie advantage. Both teams had All-Americans, with Bob Fenimore and Neill Armstrong leading Oklahoma A&M and Herman Wedemeyer leading St. Mary's.
 
"We may have been the best team in the country that year," Armstrong said. "We had a couple of All-Americans and a group of veterans who kept us in check. In practice, we scrimmaged every day. As hard as those scrimmages were, it's a wonder that we had anything left for the games, but those scrimmages toughened us and made us better. We had a lot of older guys who had fought in the war and understood that you don't win anything unless you do it as a team.
 
"Our mindset going into the Sugar Bowl and in general was that you better work hard if you're going to gain anything," Armstrong added. "We didn't mind getting hit and we didn't mind hitting other people." 
 
As Armstrong referenced, with World War II ending less than a month prior to the start of the season, Oklahoma A&M's roster included seven war veterans who went head-to-head against a St. Mary's squad that had an average age of 18 ½. The Gaels had seven 17-year-olds in the starting lineup.
 
Not only did the A&M roster feature war veterans, but it also had its share of football veterans who were key figures on the 1944 squad that finished 8-1 and won a major bowl game the year prior – an experience that Armstrong said was a contributing factor to the team's Sugar Bowl success.
 
"We played in the Cotton Bowl the year before and we knew what a big, important bowl game was like," Armstrong said. "We knew what to expect. Coach Lookabaugh got everyone ready. I give a lot of the credit for the Sugar Bowl win to the coaches because of how they prepared us."
 
Even still, it was St. Mary's who got on the board first when Wedemeyer took a handoff on a reverse, then found Dennis O'Connor downfield for a 46-yard touchdown pass.
 
The Aggies answered when Fenimore hit Cecil Hankins on a post route for a 29-yard touchdown pass, then took the lead on the back of a bruising one-yard run off the right tackle by Fenimore.
 
On the very next possession, Wedemeyer dashed for 24 yards, then lateralled to guard Carl DeSalvo, who took the ball the final 20 yards into the end zone. That play was indicative of the style of offense that St. Mary's ran. This description of Wedemeyer and the Gaels came from Hal Middlesworth of the Daily Oklahoman newspaper:
 
          "(Wedemeyer) was the key man in practically every play, many of which pulled in from three to five players to handle the ball. On one play, for instance, Wedemeyer passed to end Ed Ryan, who lateralled to O'Connor, who lateralled to tackle Al Beasley – all of which was good for 33 yards. It shows what the Aggies were up against."
 
Not only did St. Mary's flashy style of play keep it in the game during the first half, but it won over the sizable crowd in New Orleans, with many of the neutral observers gravitating toward Wedemeyer and the undersized but feisty and entertaining Gaels.
 
"Wedemeyer was good," Armstrong said. "They weren't a big team at all, but we knew that we had to make sure we didn't let him into the secondary or else we wouldn't catch him.
 
The second half was controlled by the bigger and more physical Aggies.
 

 
With just one point separating the two teams coming out of the break, Fenimore made a game-changing play when he returned a punt to the St. Mary's 6-yard line to set himself up for another punishing one-yard touchdown run four plays later for the only score of the third quarter.
 
"Fenimore one of best I've ever seen," Armstrong said. "He could run the ball and throw it. We'd take the run to the strong side and then run him back to the weak side. He had all the ability, all the speed and all the moves. He could really run."
 
Perhaps the most important play of the game came in the fourth quarter, when Wedemeyer slipped while trying to punt and missed the ball completely. Armstrong and Aggie teammate Terry Monroe recovered the miscue at the St. Mary's 35-yard line and Oklahoma A&M opened up a 25-13 lead when Jim Reynolds muscled his way in for a one-yard touchdown run on the ensuing possession.
 
The Aggies added another touchdown late to seal their win.
 
St. Mary's coach Jim Phelan summed it up like this after the game – "Too much power, too much speed. And above all, too much Fenimore."
 
Armstrong said Phelan's assessment of the game was accurate, then he added to it.
 

"Our coaches worked us hard and prepared us for the razzle-dazzle of St. Mary's and we were ready for them," Armstrong said. "The coaches instilled a confidence in us because we knew if we carried out our responsibilities and stuck to our assignments, then we'd win the game."